Secretive Seahorse
Finished
September 16, 2022
September 20, 2022

Secretive Seahorse

Project info
Secretive Seahorse by Joan Rowe
Knitting
SoftiesAnimal
Britt and Ari's baby shower
Needles & yarn
US 4 - 3.5 mm
Knitted Wit DK
0.24 skeins = 68.2 yards (62.4 meters), 28 grams
Blue-green
Notes

Pattern Errors:
-Ridge 4 of the body: The short row math seems to be off. I just knit/purled to the end of the row on rows 21 and 24. Without changing the knit/purl to 4 stitches after the GSR-Sl, the rows would never resolve and would be left with a stitch on either end that hadn’t been worked.

-Row 20 of the head should be GSR-SL1, p3, pu6 pw, p2 turn. Because of the direction of the p2togBO in the previous row.

-Row 25 of the head should be k5, turn.

Pattern Notes/modifications
-If I make this pattern again I think I will do MP3’s above the dorsal fin space for a more pronounced dorsal ridge. Also I think I’d do the front panel in a contrast color

-Because this is a baby gift, I omitted the pipe cleaner and beaded eyes

-I did mp3’s for all of the first four head ridges

-For the dorsal fin I did an extra row of increases followed by an extra row of ribbing to make the fin a little bigger. I also added picots to the cast off to match the rest of the spikes on this showy boy.

Modified dorsal fin cast off: mp2, co5, mp1, co6, mp2, co5, mp1, co5, mp2. Cut yarn and pass the yarn tail through the last stitch loop. Pull tight then sew in end to secure the last picot.

Final thoughts:
Overall I loved this pattern. I love how anatomically accurate this seahorse looks. The designer obviously put a lot of thought into this pattern. I would definitely knit this again. The pattern included detailed descriptions of the required techniques along with maby pictures illistrating the intended directions. This is a very well written pattern. That being said I did run into a few issues with this pattern. First was that it was advertised as a seamless knit and I don’t think that is accurate. This seahorse is knit in panels that are joined by picking up the edge stitches and using 3 needle bind offs. There is also some mattress stitch seaming involved. I don’t mind any of this and it makes a ton of sense both structurally and visually to knit it this way, I just wish that it hadn’t been advertised as seamless. I had imagined I would be mostly knitting in the round and would have allowed myself more time to finish the project if I knew I’d be picking up and joining edges across most or the project. Being a paid pattern, I didn’t realize this till after I had already purchased. There were also some errors in the pattern, but they were easy to resolve. All that aside, I LOVE this design and I love how my seahorse turned out so I definitely don’t regret my purchase.

viewed 175 times
Finished
September 16, 2022
September 20, 2022
About this pattern
12 projects, in 39 queues
TubieYogi's overall rating
TubieYogi's clarity rating
TubieYogi's difficulty rating
About this yarn
DK
by Knitted Wit
DK
100% Merino
280 yards / 115 grams

1768 projects

stashed 1747 times

TubieYogi's star rating
  • Project created: September 17, 2022
  • Finished: September 20, 2022
  • Updated: September 21, 2022
  • Progress updates: 3 updates