Fun to work! I couldn’t decide whether the color combo looked more like a superhero costume or Fiestaware, but it’s definitely not a rusty bucket.

I tweaked the color arrangement a bit because I was using up leftover skeins and didn’t have enough to do a couple colors as written. The bindoff is turquoise rather than royal because I ran short on the royal and my other royal skein was too obviously a different dyelot.

I’ve made several of this designer’s scarves, and I consistently get a smaller scarf and use less yarn than the pattern says. True in this case too: the pattern said her scarf used about 410 yards and was about six feet long; mine used much less and might block to five feet if I stretch it, and that’s with a heavier yarn than she used.

Berkshire makes a lovely and squishy scarf. If I were to make this pattern with this yarn again (and were starting with full skeins rather than remnants so didn’t have to worry about running out), I’d use a larger needle.

In the Green Wave and Red Wave sections, I wasn’t sure whether to count the double stitch as part of the number of stitches. I didn’t count it and made sure to be consistent throughout; if that wasn’t how it was supposed to be done, it still looks fine.

In the last sentence of the Red Edge Wave section, the first WS should be a RS.